Case Study Drafting a Real Estate Investment and Development Agreement for a Project Exceeding SAR 1 Billion in Makkah Dispute...
- Al Takhassousi, An Nakheel, Riyadh 12384
- info@al-tayyar.com.sa
- 0555398969
Case Study
Objection to the Valuation of an Inherited Property Worth More Than SAR 350 Million in Makkah
Dispute Value
SAR 350,000,000
Atyar Advocates and Legal Consultants provided legal advice and a detailed legal study to an heir challenging the valuation of an inherited property in Makkah, valued at more than SAR 350 million.The dispute concerned a court-appointed expert’s valuation that the client considered below the property’s actual market value. The firm reviewed the expert report, assessed the legal grounds for objection, and advised on seeking a fairer and more accurate revaluation of the property.
Quick Matter Overview
Nature of the Dispute
Objection to the valuation of inherited real estate
Property Value
More than SAR 350 million
Parties Concerned
Heirs
Property Location
Makkah
Scope of Work
Legal study and legal advice
Outcome of the Engagement
Legal grounds and options identified for challenging the valuation and seeking revaluation
Background of the Dispute
Nature of Estate
Real estate estate
Subject Objection
Court-appointed expert valuation report
Property Value
More than SAR 350 million
Property Location
Makkah
Nature of the Real Estate and Estate Dispute
The matter focused on the accuracy and fairness of the valuation of a property forming part of an estate, the extent to which a court-appointed expert report could be challenged, and the impact of the valuation on the heirs’ rights in the division of the estate.
- Reviewing the real estate expert report.
- Analysing the valuation methodology.
- Assessing the market value stated in the report.
- Reviewing the location and characteristics of the property.
- Evaluating the effect of the valuation on the client’s share in the estate.
- Identifying grounds for objection.
- Reviewing the rules governing expert evidence.
- Analysing relevant judicial principles.
- Identifying potential deficiencies in the valuation.
- Preparing a legal basis for requesting revaluation.
- Assessing the possibility of appointing another expert.
- Determining the appropriate procedural route before the court.
Essential Elements of the Dispute
Expert Report
Reviewing the report relied upon by the court in determining the property’s market value.
Market Value
Assessing whether the valuation accurately reflected the property’s true market value.
Heirs’ Rights
Evaluating the effect of the valuation on the financial interests and shares of the heirs.
Valuation Methodology
Analysing the basis and criteria used by the expert to reach the assessed value.
Judicial Objection
Identifying the legal basis on which the valuation report could be challenged before the court.
Revaluation
Assessing whether a fresh valuation could be requested to produce a more accurate and equitable result.
Key Legal Challenges
Valuation Prepared by a Court-Appointed Expert
The report had been prepared by an expert appointed in the course of the proceedings, giving it significant evidential weight before the court.
High Value of the Property
The property was worth more than SAR 350 million, meaning that even a relatively small valuation difference could materially affect the heirs’ financial rights.
Need for a Substantive Objection
A mere assertion that the valuation was too low would not be sufficient. The objection needed to identify specific deficiencies in the methodology, assumptions, or supporting data.
Direct Impact on Estate Division
The valuation affected not only the value of the asset but also the calculation and distribution of the heirs’ shares.
Evidential Weight of Expert Opinion
The expert’s opinion was entitled to judicial consideration, making it necessary to present a carefully reasoned and documented challenge.
Proving a Higher Market Value
The client’s position required identifying objective grounds to demonstrate that the property’s true market value was higher than the figure stated in the report.
Our Legal Strategy
Detailed Review of the Expert Report
The report was examined in detail to identify the methodology, assumptions, and valuation factors used.
Comparing the Valuation with Market Reality
The legal assessment focused on whether the expert’s conclusion reflected the actual market position of the property.
Identifying Material Deficiencies
The firm reviewed the report for omitted factors, incomplete assumptions, or other issues capable of affecting the valuation result.
Reviewing Judicial Principles on Expert Evidence
Relevant legal principles were considered concerning the court’s discretion to accept, reject, or require further expert evidence.
Building the Case for Revaluation
A legal approach was developed to support a request for a fresh valuation where the original report did not adequately reflect the property’s market value.
Protecting the Client’s Estate Rights
The strategy focused on preventing reliance on an undervaluation that could adversely affect the client’s entitlement in the division of the estate.
Legal Services Provided
Legal Study
Comprehensive analysis of the file, expert report, and legal framework governing valuation disputes.
Legal Advice
Advice on the strength of the objection and the available options for seeking revaluation.
Review of the Expert Report
Assessment of the report’s reasoning, methodology, and valuation basis.
Analysis of Objection Routes
Identification of the procedural and legal mechanisms available to challenge the report.
Risk Assessment
Evaluation of the effect of accepting the report on the client’s rights in the estate.
Legal Action Plan
Preparation of a practical route for seeking a more accurate valuation.
Legal Insight
A court-appointed expert report is not immune from review or challenge merely because it was commissioned by the court.Where the valuation does not reflect the property’s true market value, the methodology fails to account for relevant factors, or the report omits material information, there may be grounds to object and seek a fresh valuation.This is particularly significant in estate proceedings, where a material difference in valuation may directly affect the value of the heirs’ shares and the fairness of the distribution.
Legal Value Delivered to the Client
- Reviewed a dispute involving real estate worth more than SAR 350 million.
- Analysed a court-appointed expert valuation report.
- Assessed the effect of the valuation on the client’s estate rights.
- Identified legal and technical grounds of objection.
- Reviewed relevant judicial principles concerning expert evidence.
- Developed a legal strategy for requesting revaluation.
The Firm’s Experience in Estate and Real Estate Valuation Disputes
Atyar Advocates and Legal Consultants advises on disputes involving estate division, valuation of inherited property, objections to expert reports, accounting of estate agents, and distribution of real estate assets among heirs.The firm’s work includes assessing the effect of real estate valuations on beneficiaries’ shares, reviewing the reliability of expert reports, and identifying procedural and legal mechanisms for challenging expert evidence before the competent courts.
Legal Team Responsible for This Matter
Prof. Dr. Turki Al-Tayyar
Founder and Managing Partner, and an expert in the judiciary, legal practice, arbitration, and university education, with more than 25 years of combined experience.
Mr. Salem Saad Al-Dosari
Partner specialising in administrative contracts, investment, and litigation, with extensive experience in administrative and commercial cases.
Practice Areas Related to This Matter
Case Study Legal Review of a USD 4M Liquidated Damages Claim Under a USD 60M Steel Supply Contract in India...
Case Study Drafting a Real Estate Investment and Development Agreement Exceeding SAR 800 Million in Makkah Dispute Value SAR 800...
Case Study Final Criminal Judgment Imposing Imprisonment in a Defamation and Commercial Reputation Dispute Involving a Trademark and Medical Products...
Case Study Legal and Judicial Review of a USD 17 Million Liquidated Damages Claim Under a USD 30 Million International...
Case Study Legal Representation in a Medical Property Rent Dispute Exceeding SAR 10 Million in East Riyadh Dispute Value SAR...
Need Legal Advice on the Valuation of Inherited Property?
If you are involved in an estate dispute and believe that a real estate expert report does not reflect the true market value of inherited property, Atyar Advocates and Legal Consultants provides legal advice, specialist legal studies, review of expert reports, and assessment of the available objection procedures before the competent courts.
جاهز لحماية حقوقك أو تطوير أعمالك؟
تواصل معنا اليوم واحصل على استشارة قانونية موثوقة
سواء كنت فردًا تبحث عن تمثيل قانوني موثوق أو شركة تحتاج إلى دعم قانوني متخصص، نحن في شركة أطيار للمحاماة والاستشارات القانونية جاهزون لمساعدتك. دعنا نكون شريكك القانوني في كل خطوة، بخبرة تتجاوز 23 عامًا في الأنظمة السعودية.
بيانات الاتصال
- شارع التخصصي، النخيل، الرياض 12384
- 3132 شارع الأمير تركي، الكورنيش، 6309, الخبر
- Info@al-tayyar.com.sa
- 00966555398969
مجالات الممارسة
القانون التجاري والشركات
صياغة العقود والوثائق القانونية
القانون المالي والمصرفي
الضرائب والزكاة والجمارك
العقارات والملكية الخاصة
© 2025 All Right Reserved Al Tayyar Leagal company